value1

Glenrothes 1997/2015 Wemyss “Chocolate Orange Segment”

May 26, 2016

I hate to repeat myself, but time and time again there are whiskies with a great nose that dissapoint on the palate. – Rating: 80/100

Glenfarclas 2000/2013 Cask Strength Premium Edition

April 18, 2016
Thumbnail image for Glenfarclas 2000/2013 Cask Strength Premium Edition

Nice nose, weak palate and finish. As it happens all too often. – Rating: 81/100

Tomatin 14 yo Port Wood Finish

March 25, 2016
Thumbnail image for Tomatin 14 yo Port Wood Finish

Overall this feels quite watery. There are not many noteworthy flavours which makes you wonder about the quality of the base whisky used for this finish. – Rating: 77/100

Mortlach 18 yo

March 13, 2016
Thumbnail image for Mortlach 18 yo

Even though the nose is rather timid to open up, it is still the best aspect of this whisky. The palate lacks flavour and the finish lacks length. – Rating: 81/100

Tomatin 36 yo Batch 1

January 25, 2016
Thumbnail image for Tomatin 36 yo Batch 1

Old Tomatins are often very fruity and this is no exception, the subtle hint of smoke makes this excellent but expensive whisky even more interesting. – Rating: 90/100

Glen Grant 60 yo 1950/2010 Gordon & MacPhail

January 17, 2016
Thumbnail image for Glen Grant 60 yo 1950/2010 Gordon & MacPhail

The nose is simply wonderful, but on the palate the wood dominates just a bit too much, also the 40% ABV results in rather watery mouthfeel. – Rating: 86/100

Scapa Skiren

January 13, 2016
Thumbnail image for Scapa Skiren

The early palate is rather pleasant and creamy but soon gives way to the kind of edgy finish that is common for immature whiskies. – Rating: 74/100

Glenfarclas Springs

December 28, 2015
Thumbnail image for Glenfarclas Springs

Defenders of the No Age Statement concept say “It’s not about age, it’s about maturity”. They are right. But there is no maturity in this whisky. I can not remember tasting a weaker Glenfarclas. – Rating: 73/100

Glenlivet Founder’s Reserve

November 30, 2015
Thumbnail image for Glenlivet Founder’s Reserve

The nose is actually quite nice but the palate is a disappointment. While the generic flavours of this whisky will not offend anyone, its lack of maturity makes it difficult to like. – Rating: 69/100

Port Askaig 16 yo

November 24, 2015
Thumbnail image for Port Askaig 16 yo

The nose of this is very intriguing but the palate does not quite live up to the promise. The sweetness is overwhelming and despite the solid ABV the mouthfeel is a bit watery. – Rating: 82/100

Puni Alba 3 yo Batch 02/2015

November 22, 2015
Thumbnail image for Puni Alba 3 yo Batch 02/2015

Just as in the 15 months old the cask influce dominates the spirit, but it has mellowed and improved a bit. – Rating: 74/100

Caol Ila 31 yo 1983/2015 Signatory for TWE

November 11, 2015
Thumbnail image for Caol Ila 31 yo 1983/2015 Signatory for TWE

There is hardly any peatiness left in this old Caol Ila, it all has transformed into fruity aromas. The cask was a bit too generous to the angels, though. – Rating: 85/100

Glen Grant 65 yo 1950/2015 G&M For Wealth Solutions

November 6, 2015

There is remarkably little wood influence for a whisky of this age. After some time to open up, there are a lot of fruity flavours to discover, the overall character is very delicate and refined. – Rating: 90/100

Cutty Sark Blended Malt

October 13, 2015
Thumbnail image for Cutty Sark Blended Malt

One of the lesser known Cuttys. I’m afraid this is no winner. Even without the soapy touch it would be just too sweet and not flavourful enough – Rating: 67/100

Johnnie Walker “The Spice Road”

October 9, 2015
Thumbnail image for Johnnie Walker “The Spice Road”

The promised spices are present, and the malt component is actually quite pleasant, but the palate is overwhelmed by the sugar coating of sweet young grain whisky. – Rating: 71/100

Coillmor 4 yo American Oak

May 5, 2015
Thumbnail image for Coillmor 4 yo American Oak

This is one of the typical young German whiskies that strongly rely on wood extraction from fresh casks while the spirit is secondary. – Rating: 70/100

Glen Spey 1996/2009 Manager’s Choice

April 10, 2015
Thumbnail image for Glen Spey 1996/2009 Manager’s Choice

The good news: It is the best Glen Spey I have ever tasted. The bad news: It is not more than a generic nice refill bourbon whisky and at £200 it is no wonder that it is still on the shelves after 5 years. – Rating: 83/100

Glengoyne 25 yo

March 18, 2015
Thumbnail image for Glengoyne 25 yo

While the flavours of this old whisky are complex and very enjoyable the quite strong tannic wood influence and lacklustre finish prevent a higher score.

Rating: 83/100

Tamdhu 1988/2012 Malts of Scotland

January 26, 2015

Both nose and palate are fairly restrained, there really is not much interesting going on. It sips nicely but I expect a bit more from a whisky of this age. Rating: 83/100

Convalmore 36 yo Special Release 2013

January 6, 2015
Thumbnail image for Convalmore 36 yo Special Release 2013

The nose is excellent and tells of its old age, but the spices on the palate are a little too strong and the finish is a little too short for a truly remarkable whisky. – Rating: 86/100